realistichigh-schoolFeaturedEditor's Choice

The Ferryman's Daughter

H

Hans Mueller

Germany

6 min read1,102 wordsadvanced4.9 (734 ratings)

On a remote Scottish island, a young woman must decide whether to leave for university or stay to take over the ferry service that connects her community to the mainland.

The ferry horn sounded at 6 AM every morning, as reliable as the tide. Moira had woken to that sound her entire life.

The ferry horn sounded at 6 AM every morning, as reliable as the tide. Moira had woken to that sound her entire life. From her window, she could see her father on the dock, preparing the small ferry that connected Eilean Dorcha—the Dark Island—to the Scottish mainland. Seventeen families lived on the island: fishermen, artists, retirees seeking peace. All depended on the ferry her family had operated for four generations. Moira was eighteen now. The letter from Edinburgh University lay on her desk, opened and reread a hundred times: full scholarship to study marine biology, dormitory reserved, future bright and beckoning. Her father knew about the letter. He'd congratulated her, his pride genuine. But he'd said nothing else, and in his silence, Moira heard a question he would never ask: Who will run the ferry? Her older brother had left years ago, moved to London, visited once a year. Her mother had passed when Moira was twelve. It was just her and her father now, and the ferry, and the island that depended on them. "You're thinking too much again," said Mrs. Campbell, the island's eldest resident, finding Moira sitting on the harbor wall one morning. "I can see it in your face." "Is it wrong to want both?" Moira asked. "To want to leave and to want to stay?" Mrs. Campbell, who had lived on Eilean Dorcha for eighty-three years, considered this. "No, lass. It's natural. But here's what I've learned: wanting both means you have to choose. And choosing means losing something, no matter which way you turn." That didn't help. A storm came that week, as they often did. The mainland ferry service canceled its runs, but Moira's father made the crossing anyway. Dr. Murray's wife was pregnant, possibly in labor, and needed to reach the hospital. Moira went with him. She'd been making the crossing since she could walk, knew every rock and current. In rough weather, she was as competent as her father at the helm. The waves were monsters, gray and furious. Rain lashed horizontally. The small ferry groaned and rose and plunged. Mrs. Murray clung to her husband, pale with fear and pain. "Steady," Moira's father said, his hands sure on the wheel. "We've made this crossing a thousand times. We'll make it a thousand more." And they did. They delivered Mrs. Murray to the mainland hospital in time. She gave birth to a healthy girl that evening. On the return journey, calmer now, Moira's father said, "You're going to university." Moira startled. "Da—" "You're going," he repeated firmly. "You're brilliant, Moira. You could study the ocean, discover new things, make a real difference in the world. I won't be the reason you stay small." "But the ferry—" "I'll manage. Young Ian is learning. He can help." "Ian is fifteen and seasick in calm weather," Moira said flatly. Her father had no answer to that. Back on the island, Moira couldn't sleep. She walked to the harbor and found, surprisingly, Dr. Murray there, sitting on the dock. "Couldn't sleep either?" he asked. She shook her head. "My wife and daughter are safe because of you and your father," he said. "Because you were willing to risk yourselves in a storm. Because you understand that some things matter more than safety or convenience." "It's just the ferry," Moira said. "No," Dr. Murray said gently. "It's community. It's duty. It's the knowledge that if something happens, you can reach help. We live out here by choice, but only because we trust that ferry will run. Your family makes our lives possible." Moira felt the weight of his words settle on her shoulders like a heavy coat. Over the next week, she watched her island differently. She saw Mrs. Campbell receiving medication from the mainland. She saw the MacKenzie children heading to school. She saw supplies arriving, mail delivered, life continuing because a small ferry crossed the water twice daily, every day, in all weather. She thought about her dreams of studying coral reefs and ocean currents, of discovery and adventure. Beautiful dreams, important dreams. But she also thought about the storm crossing, about Mrs. Murray's frightened face, about the tiny baby who might not have survived without that reliable ferry service. Edinburgh University wasn't going anywhere. But her island needed her now. Moira found her father in the ferry's small engine room, doing maintenance. "I'm not going," she said. He looked up, oil-stained hands pausing. "Moira—" "Not yet," she clarified. "I'll defer for a year. Maybe two. We'll train Ian properly. We'll find someone else who can learn. But Da, you can't do this alone. And I can't leave knowing you're trying to." Her father's eyes filled with tears. "It's too much to ask of you." "You're not asking. I'm choosing." She smiled. "Maybe I'll love it. Maybe I'll discover I hate it. But I need to know. I need to at least try to be the person who holds this community together." "And your studies?" "The ocean will still be there. The university will still be there. But right now, this island needs me. These people need me. And maybe..." she paused, finding the truth, "maybe I need them too." That summer, Moira became her father's official co-captain. She learned navigation, engine repair, weather prediction. She learned the names of every family, every child, every regular passenger. She learned the satisfaction of reliable service, of duty fulfilled. On stormy days, when the crossing was difficult and dangerous, she remembered why she'd chosen to stay. On calm days, when the water was glass and the islands rose like emeralds from blue silk, she couldn't imagine being anywhere else. She still thought about university. About marine biology. About the life she might have had. But she had this life instead: the horn at 6 AM, the engine's familiar rumble, the grateful nods of islanders heading to the mainland, the knowledge that she was needed, essential, part of something larger than herself. Perhaps that was its own kind of education. Its own kind of discovery. Moira stood at the ferry's wheel, guiding her community across the water, and understood that some journeys are about going out into the world, while others are about diving deeper into the place you call home. Both are valid. Both are brave. Both are necessary. She had made her choice. She would live with it, and maybe, someday, it would feel less like sacrifice and more like purpose. The ferry horn sounded as she approached the mainland dock. Behind her, Eilean Dorcha rose dark and beautiful from the sea. Ahead, the world waited. She would carry her island with her always, in the salt on her skin and the rhythm of waves in her blood. And whether she stayed forever or left someday, she would know she had given this place her best self when it needed her most. That, she decided, was enough.

Region

europe

Published

August 12, 2016

Discussion Questions

  1. 1.

    What are the different kinds of "journeys" mentioned in the story, and what does each represent?

    Suggested answer: The physical ferry journey represents service and connection. Moira's potential journey to university represents personal growth and ambition. The metaphorical journey of "diving deeper into home" represents finding meaning in community and duty. All are presented as equally valid paths.

  2. 2.

    How does the storm crossing scene function as a turning point in Moira's decision-making?

  3. 3.

    Is Moira's decision to stay (even temporarily) presented as a sacrifice or as fulfillment? Support your answer.

Teaching Resources

Writing Prompts

  • Write about a time when you had to choose between competing desires or obligations. How did you decide, and how do you feel about that choice now?
    • - Be honest about the difficulty of the choice
    • - Explore both options fully
    • - Acknowledge that all choices involve trade-offs
  • Imagine a community that depends on one essential service. What happens when that service is threatened?

Key Vocabulary

  • defer: To postpone or delay, especially enrollment in a program
    "Moira decided to defer her university enrollment for a year."
  • duty: A moral or legal obligation; a responsibility
    "She felt a duty to her community and to her father."
  • helm: The steering apparatus of a ship; also metaphorically, a position of leadership
    "At the helm of the ferry, Moira felt confident and capable."

My Notes (0)

No notes yet. Click the button above to add your first note.